I seem to remember it being considered bad form to run say 7 "identical" leds in parrallel with one resistor. Is this still true?
I say identical but what I mean is 7 LEDs from the same manufacturer, same part and theoretically the same specs.
I'm not trying to save cost but trying to save board space. Some times all will be on at once, sometimes only some of them will be on at one time.
Parallel LEDs prohibition
- Chris Smith
- Posts: 4325
- Joined: Tue Dec 04, 2001 1:01 am
- Location: Bieber Ca.
Yes, BUT,...if you measure the highest draw of all the LEDS and then run the over all power level at less than the highest draw value Led, then and only then is it safe to use one resistor.
But, the LEDs will still not be equal in brightness.
In other words, run the heaviest draw Led at say, 75% of its power rating, while running all the other Leds at even less, and you will be at least “safeâ€
But, the LEDs will still not be equal in brightness.
In other words, run the heaviest draw Led at say, 75% of its power rating, while running all the other Leds at even less, and you will be at least “safeâ€
Hi there,
I did a quite complete analysis on this on another site and
found out that with parallel LED's and only one resistor
one LED could be drawing much more current than the
others so it's not too practical to do this. By 'practical',
i mean that you want to get as much brightness out
of the LED's as you can with out risking any of them.
For more complete discussions on LED's, see CandlePower Forums.
The analysis appears in one of the sticky subjects in
"Flashlight Electronics" under "CPF University -- EE Course".
Take care,
Al
I did a quite complete analysis on this on another site and
found out that with parallel LED's and only one resistor
one LED could be drawing much more current than the
others so it's not too practical to do this. By 'practical',
i mean that you want to get as much brightness out
of the LED's as you can with out risking any of them.
For more complete discussions on LED's, see CandlePower Forums.
The analysis appears in one of the sticky subjects in
"Flashlight Electronics" under "CPF University -- EE Course".
Take care,
Al
LEDs vs Bulbs, LEDs are winning.
-
- Posts: 2277
- Joined: Wed Nov 24, 2004 1:01 am
- Location: ASHTABULA,OHIO
- Contact:
First, I made an error, it's only 5 LEDs, not 7.
I'm making an LED matrix. I made an error and set it up so that 5 LEDs would share a resistor. It was going to be tricky to redesign the board but I just bit the bullet and did it right.
The reason I'm only using 4ma is because a: I'm working on a very low powered circuit and b: a PIC is sinking all of the current, and it can handle at most 25ma per i/o pin.
I'm making an LED matrix. I made an error and set it up so that 5 LEDs would share a resistor. It was going to be tricky to redesign the board but I just bit the bullet and did it right.
The reason I'm only using 4ma is because a: I'm working on a very low powered circuit and b: a PIC is sinking all of the current, and it can handle at most 25ma per i/o pin.
Assuming the supply is a fixed voltage then the resistor value sets the current through all of the LED's so if you set the resistor value for 4mA so with one led on then that led will get 4mA if 2 led's are on each will get 2mA (assuming identical LED's) and 1ma if 4 LED are on. which will cause the LED to dim as more of them are switched on.
you can use one resistor if you use some form of time division multiplexing only alowing one led oan at any time.
Colin
you can use one resistor if you use some form of time division multiplexing only alowing one led oan at any time.
Colin
I have been putting LED's parallel for quite a number of years. One of the latest projects is a flashing name badge. The letter K has 9ea T1 LED's in parallel. It is working off a 3V lithium battery with a 2N3904 as a driver. The current limiting resistor is 43 ohms. Each LED consumes about 3-4 Ma. The same badge the letter P has 7 LED's in parallel with a current limiting resistor of 62 ohms.
I have built miniature Christmas light strings with red, yellow and green LED's all in parallel in a string of about 50 LED's The string is powered by a pair of C cells in series with a 3A schotky diode. The string was built about 10 years ago and still works today. I don't remember ever replacing a LED.
A number of years ago I wired a live horse with over 150 red LED's It was for a night parade. There was a string down each leg. One string on
each side of his head. There were two battery packs built just like the one described for the Christmas lights above, to power all the LED's.
So I say you can wire LED's in parallel.
I have built miniature Christmas light strings with red, yellow and green LED's all in parallel in a string of about 50 LED's The string is powered by a pair of C cells in series with a 3A schotky diode. The string was built about 10 years ago and still works today. I don't remember ever replacing a LED.
A number of years ago I wired a live horse with over 150 red LED's It was for a night parade. There was a string down each leg. One string on
each side of his head. There were two battery packs built just like the one described for the Christmas lights above, to power all the LED's.
So I say you can wire LED's in parallel.
- Chris Smith
- Posts: 4325
- Joined: Tue Dec 04, 2001 1:01 am
- Location: Bieber Ca.
At lower currents, ALL Leds are quite happy with ANY configuration below their specs.
However pushing Leds to their normal limits of currents or brightness in parallel with a single resistor, or past this level, is where all the problems arise.
A Space saver tire is quite happy doing 35mph on the way to the garage.
Try it at 100mph and see what happens.
However pushing Leds to their normal limits of currents or brightness in parallel with a single resistor, or past this level, is where all the problems arise.
A Space saver tire is quite happy doing 35mph on the way to the garage.
Try it at 100mph and see what happens.
-
- Posts: 458
- Joined: Thu Feb 05, 2004 1:01 am
- Location: Minneapolis, MN
- Contact:
Matt:
Here's a configuration I used that you may want to try, since you have a PIC in the circuit.
I recently built a PC board to drive 16 LEDs (among other things) and I forgot the resistors! That's right: power drivers sending 12V straight to the LEDs. What saved my bacon was PWM. I calculated a duty cycle to provide approximately 1.4 volts to the LEDs and drove them that way.
Since you are using 5 LEDs you can PWM them at a variable rate that keeps current at a constant ratio of number of ON LEDs. e.g. for 1 LED on, use 20% duty cycle, for 2 use 40% and so on. This should even out the brightness as LEDs turn on and off and you won't need any resistors at all.
This works because the LEDs can handle the full power supply voltage, but heat will kill them and the PWM makes sure they never get hot.
Here's a configuration I used that you may want to try, since you have a PIC in the circuit.
I recently built a PC board to drive 16 LEDs (among other things) and I forgot the resistors! That's right: power drivers sending 12V straight to the LEDs. What saved my bacon was PWM. I calculated a duty cycle to provide approximately 1.4 volts to the LEDs and drove them that way.
Since you are using 5 LEDs you can PWM them at a variable rate that keeps current at a constant ratio of number of ON LEDs. e.g. for 1 LED on, use 20% duty cycle, for 2 use 40% and so on. This should even out the brightness as LEDs turn on and off and you won't need any resistors at all.
This works because the LEDs can handle the full power supply voltage, but heat will kill them and the PWM makes sure they never get hot.
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: Ahrefs [Bot] and 1 guest